navidocs/intelligence/session-5/session-5-readiness-report.md

# Session 5 Readiness Report
## Evidence Synthesis & Guardian Validation

**Session ID:** S5
**Coordinator:** Sonnet
**Swarm:** 10 Haiku agents (S5-H01 through S5-H10)
**Status:** 🟡 READY - Methodology prep complete, waiting for Sessions 1-4
**Generated:** 2025-11-13

---

## Phase 1: Methodology Preparation (COMPLETE ✅)

**Completed Tasks:**
1. ✅ IF.bus protocol reviewed (SWARM_COMMUNICATION_PROTOCOL.md)
2. ✅ IF.TTT framework understood (≥2 sources, confidence scores, citations)
3. ✅ Guardian evaluation criteria prepared (3 dimensions: Empirical, Logical, Practical)
4. ✅ Guardian briefing templates created (20 guardian-specific frameworks)
5. ✅ Output directory initialized (intelligence/session-5/)

**Deliverables:**
- `intelligence/session-5/guardian-evaluation-criteria.md` (4.3KB)
- `intelligence/session-5/guardian-briefing-template.md` (13.8KB)
- `intelligence/session-5/session-5-readiness-report.md` (this file)

---

## Phase 2: Evidence Validation (BLOCKED 🔵)

**Dependencies:**
- ❌ `intelligence/session-1/session-1-handoff.md` - NOT READY
- ❌ `intelligence/session-2/session-2-handoff.md` - NOT READY
- ❌ `intelligence/session-3/session-3-handoff.md` - NOT READY
- ❌ `intelligence/session-4/session-4-handoff.md` - NOT READY

**Polling Strategy:**
```bash
# Check every 5 minutes for all 4 handoff files
if [ -f "intelligence/session-1/session-1-handoff.md" ] &&
   [ -f "intelligence/session-2/session-2-handoff.md" ] &&
   [ -f "intelligence/session-3/session-3-handoff.md" ] &&
   [ -f "intelligence/session-4/session-4-handoff.md" ]; then
  echo "✅ All sessions complete - Guardian validation starting"
  # Deploy Agents 1-10
fi
```

**Next Actions (when dependencies met):**
1. Deploy Agent 1 (S5-H01): Extract evidence from Session 1
2. Deploy Agent 2 (S5-H02): Validate Session 2 technical claims
3. Deploy Agent 3 (S5-H03): Review Session 3 sales materials
4. Deploy Agent 4 (S5-H04): Assess Session 4 implementation feasibility
5. Deploy Agent 5 (S5-H05): Compile master citation database
6. Deploy Agent 6 (S5-H06): Check cross-session consistency
7. Deploy Agent 7 (S5-H07): Prepare 20 Guardian briefings
8. Deploy Agent 8 (S5-H08): Score evidence quality
9. Deploy Agent 9 (S5-H09): Compile final dossier
10. Deploy Agent 10 (S5-H10): Coordinate Guardian vote

---

## Guardian Council Configuration

**Total Guardians:** 20
**Voting Threshold:** >90% approval (18/20 guardians)

**Guardian Breakdown:**
- **Core Guardians (6):** Empiricism, Verificationism, Fallibilism, Falsificationism, Coherentism, Pragmatism
- **Western Philosophers (3):** Aristotle, Kant, Russell
- **Eastern Philosophers (3):** Confucius, Nagarjuna, Zhuangzi
- **IF.sam Light Side (4):** Ethical Idealist, Visionary Optimist, Democratic Collaborator, Transparent Communicator
- **IF.sam Dark Side (4):** Pragmatic Survivor, Strategic Manipulator, Ends-Justify-Means, Corporate Diplomat

**Evaluation Dimensions:**
1. **Empirical Soundness (0-10):** Evidence quality, source verification
2. **Logical Coherence (0-10):** Internal consistency, argument validity
3. **Practical Viability (0-10):** Implementation feasibility, ROI justification

**Approval Formula:**
- APPROVE: Average ≥7.0
- ABSTAIN: Average 5.0-6.9
- REJECT: Average <5.0

---

## IF.TTT Compliance Framework

**Evidence Standards:**
- ✅ All claims require ≥2 independent sources
- ✅ Citations include: file:line, URLs with SHA-256, git commits
- ✅ Status tracking: unverified → verified → disputed → revoked
- ✅ Source quality tiers: Primary (8-10), Secondary (5-7), Tertiary (2-4)

**Target Metrics:**
- Evidence quality: >85% verified claims
- Average credibility: ≥7.5 / 10
- Primary sources: >70% of all claims
- Unverified claims: <10%

---

## IF.bus Communication Protocol

**Message Schema:**
```json
{
  "performative": "inform | request | query-if | confirm | disconfirm | ESCALATE",
  "sender": "if://agent/session-5/haiku-X",
  "receiver": ["if://agent/session-5/haiku-Y"],
  "conversation_id": "if://conversation/navidocs-session-5-2025-11-13",
  "content": {
    "claim": "[Guardian critique, consensus findings]",
    "evidence": ["[Citation links]"],
    "confidence": 0.85,
    "cost_tokens": 1247
  },
  "citation_ids": ["if://citation/uuid"],
  "timestamp": "2025-11-13T10:00:00Z",
  "sequence_num": 1
}
```

**Communication Pattern:**
```
Agents 1-9 (Evidence Extraction) ──→ Agent 10 (Synthesis)
          ↓                              ↓
   IF.TTT Validation            Guardian Vote Coordination
          ↓                              ↓
Cross-Session Consistency      IF.sam Debate (Light vs Dark)
          ↓                              ↓
   ESCALATE (if conflicts)      Consensus Tally (>90% target)
```

---

## ESCALATE Triggers

**Agent 10 must ESCALATE if:**
1. **<80% Guardian approval:** Weak consensus requires human review
2. **>20% Guardian rejection:** Fundamental flaws detected
3. **IF.sam Light/Dark split >30%:** Ethical vs pragmatic tension unresolved
4. **Cross-session contradictions >10:** Inconsistencies between Sessions 1-4
5. **Unverified claims >10%:** Evidence quality below threshold
6. **Evidence conflicts >20% variance:** Agent findings diverge significantly

---

## Budget Allocation

**Session 5 Budget:** $25
**Breakdown:**
- Sonnet coordination: 15,000 tokens (~$0.50)
- Haiku swarm (10 agents): 60,000 tokens (~$0.60)
- Guardian vote coordination: 50,000 tokens (~$0.50)
- Dossier compilation: 25,000 tokens (~$0.25)
- **Total estimated:** ~$1.85 / $25 budget (7.4% utilization)

**IF.optimise Target:** 70% Haiku delegation

---

## Success Criteria

**Minimum Viable Output:**
- ✅ Intelligence dossier compiled (all sessions synthesized)
- ✅ Guardian Council vote achieved (>90% approval target)
- ✅ Citation database complete (≥80% verified claims)
- ✅ Evidence quality scorecard (credibility ≥7.0 average)

**Stretch Goals:**
- 🎯 100% Guardian consensus (all 20 approve)
- 🎯 95%+ verified claims (only 5% unverified)
- 🎯 Primary sources dominate (≥70% of claims)
- 🎯 Zero contradictions between sessions

---

## Coordination Status

**Current State:**
- **Session 1:** 🟡 READY (not started)
- **Session 2:** 🟡 READY (not started)
- **Session 3:** 🟡 READY (not started)
- **Session 4:** 🟡 READY (not started)
- **Session 5:** 🟡 READY - Methodology prep complete

**Expected Timeline:**
- t=0min: Sessions 1-4 start in parallel
- t=30-90min: Sessions 1-4 complete sequentially
- t=90min: Session 5 receives all 4 handoff files
- t=90-150min: Session 5 validates evidence, coordinates Guardian vote
- t=150min: Session 5 completes with final dossier

**Polling Interval:** Every 5 minutes for handoff files

---

## Next Steps

**Immediate (BLOCKED):**
1. Poll coordination status: `git fetch origin navidocs-cloud-coordination`
2. Check handoff files: `ls intelligence/session-{1,2,3,4}/*handoff.md`
3. Wait for all 4 sessions to complete

**Once Unblocked:**
1. Deploy 10 Haiku agents (S5-H01 through S5-H10)
2. Extract evidence from Sessions 1-4
3. Validate claims with IF.TTT standards
4. Prepare Guardian briefings (20 files)
5. Coordinate Guardian Council vote
6. Compile final intelligence dossier
7. Update coordination status
8. Commit to `navidocs-cloud-coordination` branch

---

## Contact & Escalation

**Session Coordinator:** Sonnet (Session 5)
**Human Oversight:** Danny
**Escalation Path:** Create `intelligence/session-5/ESCALATION-[issue].md`

**Status:** 🟡 READY - Awaiting Sessions 1-4 completion

---

**Report Signature:**
```
if://doc/session-5/readiness-report-2025-11-13
Created: 2025-11-13T[timestamp]
Status: Phase 1 complete, Phase 2 blocked on dependencies
Next Poll: Every 5 minutes for handoff files
```