Danny Stocker da1263d1b3 Add IF.bus intra-agent communication protocol to all 5 cloud sessions

- Added IFMessage schema with FIPA-ACL performatives
- Session-specific communication flows (distributed intelligence, peer review, adversarial testing, sequential handoffs, consensus building)
- Automatic conflict detection (>20% variance triggers ESCALATE)
- Multi-source verification (IF.TTT ≥2 sources requirement)
- Token cost tracking (IF.optimise integration)
- PARALLEL_LAUNCH_STRATEGY.md for simultaneous session deployment
- SWARM_COMMUNICATION_PROTOCOL.md comprehensive protocol docs

Based on InfraFabric S² multi-swarm coordination (3,563x faster than git polling)

🤖 Generated with Claude Code
Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>

2025-11-13 02:03:24 +01:00

15 KiB

Raw Export PDF Blame History

Cloud Session 1: Yacht Sales Market Intelligence

NaviDocs × Riviera Plaisance Opportunity Analysis

Session Type: Market Research Coordinator Lead Agent: Sonnet (strategic intelligence) Swarm Size: 10 Haiku agents Token Budget: $15 (7.5K Sonnet + 50K Haiku) Output: Market analysis + competitive landscape

Mission Statement

Gather comprehensive market intelligence for Riviera Plaisance Euro Voiles, focusing on recreational motor boat owners (Jeanneau Prestige + Sunseeker 40-60ft, €800K-€1.5M range) and the daily boat management pain points that NaviDocs solves with sticky engagement features.

Context (Read First)

NaviDocs: Daily boat management app with sticky engagement (cameras, maintenance logs, inventory tracking) that happens to have perfect documentation when you need it.

Meeting: Riviera Plaisance yacht sales agent (Sylvain) - pitch NaviDocs as included service with every boat sale

Riviera Plaisance Euro Voiles Profile:

Location: Antibes, Golfe Juan, Beaulieu (French Riviera)
Brands: Jeanneau, Prestige Yachts, Fountaine Pajot, Monte Carlo Yachts
Volume: 150+ new boats/year, 20,500+ active customers
Boat Types: Recreational motor boats 40-50ft (€800K-€1.5M range)
Owner Profile: Weekend/holiday users (20-40 days/year), NOT crew-managed mega yachts

Current NaviDocs Status:

65% complete MVP
Production-ready architecture (13 tables, 40+ APIs)
OCR pipeline functional (Tesseract + Google Vision)
Multi-tenant ready
Critical Gap: Lacks sticky daily-use features (cameras, maintenance, inventory, contacts)

Key Insights from Local Research:

Inventory tracking pain: Owners forget €15K-€50K in upgrades when selling (tender, electronics, blinds)
Passive docs don't work: Owners ignore documentation vault until emergency/sale
Sticky features needed: Camera check, maintenance log, crew contacts, expense tracking
Warranty tracking: Still valuable (€8K-€33K losses) but secondary to daily engagement
Search UX critical: No long lists - structured, impeccable search results

Agent Identity & Check-In Protocol

YOU ARE: Sonnet coordinator for Session 1 (Market Research)

YOUR HAIKU SWARM: You have 10 Haiku agents available. Use as many as needed (not required to use all 10).

AGENT IDENTITY SYSTEM: When spawning a Haiku agent, assign it an identity: S1-H01 through S1-H10 Each agent MUST:

Check in at start: "I am S1-H03, assigned to [task name]"
Reference their task by searching this document for "Agent 3:" (matching their number)
Retain identity throughout execution
Report completion with identity: "S1-H03 complete: [deliverable summary]"

TASK DEPENDENCIES:

Agents 1-9 can run in parallel (no dependencies)
Agent 10 (Evidence Synthesis) MUST wait for Agents 1-9 to complete

Your Tasks (Use Haiku Agents S1-H01 through S1-H10 as Needed)

Agent 1: Recreational Boat Market (Prestige + Sunseeker)

AGENT ID: S1-H01 PERSONA: Joe Trader (Epic V4 Merchant-Philosopher) - detect discontinuities, market trends Research:

ACTUAL SALE PRICES: Search YachtWorld, Boat Trader ads for current + historical sales
Price trend analysis 2020-2025 (COVID boom impact, current market)
Jeanneau Prestige + Sunseeker 40-60ft market (units sold annually, €800K-€1.5M range)
Riviera Plaisance Euro Voiles volume (150+ boats/year validated)
Owner demographics (age, usage patterns, pain points)
Boat ownership costs (maintenance, storage, upgrades)

Deliverable: Market report with ACTUAL sale data + trend analysis (Joe Trader discontinuity lens)

Agent 2 Competitor Analysis (Boat Management Apps)

AGENT ID: S1-H02 ** Research:

Boat management apps (Savvy Navvy, Dockwa, Boat Buddy, BoatVault, DeckDocs)
Daily engagement features (cameras, maintenance logs, inventory tracking)
Pricing models (€5-€50/month for consumer apps)
Feature gaps: Do they solve "forgot €15K tender" problem?
Customer reviews: What makes boat apps sticky vs abandoned?

Deliverable: Competitive matrix showing NaviDocs differentiation (daily engagement + perfect docs)

Agent 3 Owner Pain Points (Daily Boat Management)

AGENT ID: S1-H03 ** Research:

What frustrates recreational boat owners? (maintenance tracking, expense tracking, remote monitoring)
"Forgot to sell the tender" problem - how common is inventory loss at resale?
Camera/remote monitoring needs (is my boat OK while I'm away?)
Crew/service contact management (who do I call for cleaning/repairs?)
Accounting pain (how much am I spending on this boat annually?)

Deliverable: Owner pain point analysis ranked by frequency and financial impact

Agent 4 Inventory Tracking & Resale Value Protection

AGENT ID: S1-H04 ** Research:

Boat equipment upgrade market (tenders, electronics, deck refinishing, automatic systems)
Average upgrade spend per boat per year (Jeanneau Prestige + Sunseeker 40-60ft owners)
"Forgotten inventory" problem - how much value is lost at resale?
Receipt/invoice management for boats (tax deduction, warranty claims, resale documentation)
Comparable: RV/car inventory tracking solutions

Deliverable: ROI calculator for inventory tracking (€X forgotten value prevented)

Agent 5 Sticky Engagement Feature Research

AGENT ID: S1-H05 ** Research:

Boat camera/monitoring systems (Siren Marine, GOST, Nautic Alert)
Maintenance reminder apps (what makes them sticky vs ignored?)
Expense tracking for recreational vehicles (boats, RVs, classic cars)
Contact management for boat services (marina, mechanics, cleaners, charter crew)
User engagement metrics: daily active users for boat apps

Deliverable: Feature prioritization - which sticky features drive daily/weekly engagement?

Agent 6 Search UX Best Practices (Critical for Inventory)

AGENT ID: S1-H06 ** Research:

Search UX for inventory/asset management (how to avoid long lists?)
Structured search results (Pinterest, Amazon, Airbnb approaches)
Filtering/faceting for boat equipment (by zone, category, value, warranty status)
Mobile-first search (owners check from phone)
Voice search for boat management ("Show me tender warranty")

Deliverable: Search UX recommendations - impeccable structured results, zero long lists

Agent 7 Pricing Strategy Research (Broker-Included Model)

AGENT ID: S1-H07 ** Research:

"Included with purchase" software models (Tesla app, luxury car apps)
Broker/dealer software bundling strategies
Freemium boat apps (free basic, paid premium features)
Monthly subscription tolerance (€5-€20/month for boat owners?)
Revenue share models (broker pays €X per boat sold, owner pays ongoing)

Deliverable: Pricing recommendation for "included with every Riviera boat" model

Agent 8 Home Assistant & Camera Integration Research

AGENT ID: S1-H08 ** Research:

Home Assistant boat monitoring setups (camera feeds, bilge sensors, battery monitoring)
Marine camera systems compatible with HA (Hikvision, Reolink, marine-rated cameras)
Boat monitoring hardware (Victron, Siren Marine, GOST integrations)
Remote boat access use cases (security, maintenance alerts, peace of mind)
API integration patterns (webhook, MQTT, REST)

Deliverable: Technical feasibility report for Home Assistant/camera integration

Agent 9 Broker Sales Objection Research

AGENT ID: S1-H09 ** Research:

Why brokers resist including software with boat sales (complexity, support burden)
Owner adoption challenges (will they actually use it after purchase?)
Sticky product examples (what makes owners keep using bundled software?)
Success stories: software included with high-ticket purchases (luxury cars, boats, RVs)
"I already use X" objections (existing boat management apps)

Deliverable: Objection handling playbook for Sylvain meeting

Agent 10 Evidence Synthesis

AGENT ID: S1-H10 ** Research:

Compile all findings from Agents 1-9
Cross-reference data for consistency
Identify gaps requiring additional research
Flag unverified claims needing validation

Deliverable: Master evidence database with citations

Intra-Agent Communication Protocol (IF.bus)

Based on: InfraFabric S² multi-swarm coordination (3,563x faster than git polling)

IFMessage Schema

Every agent-to-agent message follows this structure:

{
  "performative": "inform",  // FIPA-ACL: inform, request, query-if, confirm, disconfirm, ESCALATE
  "sender": "if://agent/session-1/haiku-Y",
  "receiver": ["if://agent/session-1/haiku-Z"],
  "conversation_id": "if://conversation/navidocs-session-1-2025-11-13",
  "content": {
    "claim": "[Your finding]",
    "evidence": ["[URL or file:line]"],
    "confidence": 0.85,  // 0.0-1.0
    "cost_tokens": 1247
  },
  "citation_ids": ["if://citation/uuid"],
  "timestamp": "2025-11-13T10:00:00Z",
  "sequence_num": 1
}

Speech Acts (Performatives)

inform: Share findings with synthesis agent (Agent 10)

Example: "I am S1-H03. Inventory tracking prevents €15K-€50K loss (confidence 0.85)"

request: Ask another agent for verification/data

Example: "S1-H10 requests S1-H02: Verify market size with 2nd source (IF.TTT requirement)"

confirm: Validate another agent's claim

Example: "S1-H02 confirms S1-H01: Market size €2.3B verified (2 sources now)"

disconfirm: Challenge another agent's claim

Example: "S1-H03 challenges S1-H01: Price range conflict (€250K vs €1.5M = 500% variance)"

ESCALATE: Flag critical conflict for Sonnet coordinator

Example: "S1-H10 ESCALATES: Price variance >20%, requires human resolution"

Communication Flow (This Session)

S1-H01 through S1-H09 → S1-H10 (Evidence Synthesis)
                           ↓
                      ESCALATE (if conflicts)
                           ↓
                      Sonnet Resolves

Key Patterns:

Agents 1-9 → Agent 10: Send findings with confidence scores
Agent 10 → Agents 1-9: Request verification if confidence <0.75
Agent 10 → Sonnet: ESCALATE conflicts (>20% variance)
Sonnet → Agent X: Request re-investigation with specific instructions

Multi-Source Verification Example

# Agent 1 finds data (1 source, low confidence)
S1-H01: "inform" → claim: "Market size €2.3B", confidence: 0.70

# Agent 10 detects low confidence, requests verification
S1-H10: "request" → S1-H02: "Verify market size (IF.TTT: need 2+ sources)"

# Agent 2 searches, finds 2nd source
S1-H02: "confirm" → S1-H10: "Market size €2.3B verified", confidence: 0.90

# Agent 10 synthesizes
S1-H10: "inform" → Coordinator: "Market size €2.3B (VERIFIED, 2 sources)"

Conflict Detection Example

# Agents report conflicting data
S1-H01: "inform" → "Prestige 50 price €250K"
S1-H03: "inform" → "Owner has €1.5M Prestige 50"

# Agent 10 detects 500% variance
S1-H10: "ESCALATE" → Coordinator: "Price conflict requires resolution"

# Sonnet resolves
Coordinator: "request" → S1-H01: "Re-search YachtWorld for Prestige 50 SOLD prices"

# Agent 1 corrects
S1-H01: "inform" → "Prestige 50 price €800K-€1.5M (CORRECTED)"

IF.TTT Compliance

Every message MUST include:

citation_ids: Links to evidence
confidence: Explicit score (0.0-1.0)
evidence: Observable artifacts (URLs, file:line)
cost_tokens: Token consumption (IF.optimise tracking)

IF.optimise Protocol

Token Efficiency Targets:

Use Haiku for all web research and data extraction
Use Sonnet only for final synthesis and strategic analysis
Target: 70% Haiku delegation (10% better than 14-day sprint)

Cost Tracking:

Report token consumption per agent
Alert if exceeding $15 budget
Switch to Haiku-only mode if approaching limit

Output Format

Deliverable 1: Market Analysis Report

File: session-1-market-analysis.md

Structure:

# Yacht Sales Market Intelligence Report
## Mediterranean Focus - Riviera Plaisance Opportunity

### Executive Summary
- Market size: [€X billion, Y thousand yachts sold annually]
- Riviera broker market: [Z brokerages, avg A boats/year]
- Opportunity: [€B revenue potential for NaviDocs]

### Market Sizing
[Agent 1 findings with citations]

### Competitive Landscape
[Agent 2 competitive matrix]

### Broker Pain Points
[Agent 3 pain point analysis]

### Value Proposition
[Agent 4 ROI calculator data]

### Regulatory Requirements
[Agent 5 compliance checklist]

### Charter Fleet Market
[Agent 6 charter feature needs]

### Pricing Strategy
[Agent 7 pricing recommendations]

### Integration Partnerships
[Agent 8 integration targets]

### Sales Enablement
[Agent 9 objection handling]

### Evidence Quality
[Agent 10 verification status]
- Total claims: X
- Verified claims: Y (Z%)
- Citations: [if://citation/uuid list]

Deliverable 2: Citations Database

File: session-1-citations.json

Format:

{
  "session_id": "if://conversation/navidocs-session-1-2025-11-13",
  "citations": [
    {
      "citation_id": "if://citation/market-size-mediterranean-yachts",
      "claim": "Mediterranean yacht sales market is €2.3B annually",
      "sources": [
        {
          "type": "web",
          "url": "https://example.com/yacht-market-report-2024",
          "accessed": "2025-11-13T10:00:00Z",
          "hash": "sha256:..."
        }
      ],
      "status": "verified",
      "created_by": "if://agent/session-1/haiku-1"
    }
  ]
}

Deliverable 3: Session Handoff

File: session-1-handoff.md