navidocs/README_ARCHITECTURE_ANALYSIS.md
Danny Stocker 58b344aa31 FINAL: P0 blockers fixed + Joe Trader + ignore binaries
Fixed:
- Price: €800K-€1.5M, Sunseeker added
- Agent 1: Joe Trader persona + actual sale ads research
- Ignored meilisearch binary + data/ (too large for GitHub)
- SESSION_DEBUG_BLOCKERS.md created

Ready for Session 1 launch.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code
2025-11-13 01:29:59 +01:00

288 lines
9.8 KiB
Markdown

# NaviDocs Architecture Analysis - Document Index
**Analysis Completed:** 2025-11-13
**Analyzer:** Claude Code (Haiku 4.5)
**Scope:** Medium thoroughness analysis
**Project Context:** Yacht Sales & Marine Asset Documentation
---
## Quick Navigation
### For Executives / Product Managers
Start here:
- **ARCHITECTURE_ANALYSIS_SUMMARY.txt** (2KB text)
- Key findings, gaps, recommended roadmap
- Integration readiness assessment
- Timeline estimates for new features
### For Software Architects
Read in order:
1. **ARCHITECTURE_INTEGRATION_ANALYSIS.md** (32KB, 916 lines)
- Complete technical deep-dive
- Database schema analysis with examples
- All API endpoints documented
- Integration points mapped
- Security architecture review
2. **INTEGRATION_QUICK_REFERENCE.md** (11KB, 418 lines)
- Code templates and patterns
- Database migration examples
- Service layer extension points
- Testing procedures
### For Developers Implementing Features
Use as lookup:
- **INTEGRATION_QUICK_REFERENCE.md**
- Database key tables section
- API route templates
- Service layer patterns
- Code examples for common integrations
- Yacht sales specific examples
---
## Document Contents Summary
### ARCHITECTURE_ANALYSIS_SUMMARY.txt
**Type:** Plain text executive summary
**Length:** 4.5KB
Sections:
1. Key Findings (production-ready status)
2. Database Schema (13 tables, yacht-sales optimized)
3. API Coverage (40+ endpoints, 12 route files)
4. Background Processing (BullMQ + Redis)
5. Frontend Capabilities (Vue 3 + 7 views)
6. Integration Readiness Assessment
7. Gaps for Yacht Sales (5 critical, 3 medium priority)
8. Recommended Next Steps (3 phases)
9. Architecture Strengths (5 major areas)
10. Conclusion and Timeline
### ARCHITECTURE_INTEGRATION_ANALYSIS.md
**Type:** Detailed markdown technical analysis
**Length:** 32KB, 916 lines, 12 major sections
Complete Contents:
1. **Executive Summary** - Overview and gap analysis
2. **Database Schema Analysis** - All 13 tables with relationships
3. **API Endpoints & Capabilities** - All routes documented
4. **Frontend Architecture** - Views, components, libraries
5. **Background Workers & Services** - 11 services documented
6. **Integration Points** - 8 potential integrations identified
7. **Offline-First PWA** - Current state and gaps
8. **Security Architecture** - What's implemented vs. needed
9. **Current Capabilities vs Yacht Sales Use Case** - Feature matrix
10. **File Structure Reference** - Complete project layout
11. **Recommended Integration Roadmap** - 3 phases with details
12. **Database Migration Plan** - SQL for new tables/columns
### INTEGRATION_QUICK_REFERENCE.md
**Type:** Developer quick reference guide
**Length:** 11KB, 418 lines
Quick Lookup Sections:
1. **Database Key Tables** - JSON metadata examples for integration
2. **API Route Templates** - Webhook receiver and event publisher patterns
3. **Service Layer Extension Points** - How to add to search, queue, auth
4. **Common Integration Patterns** - 3 code examples
5. **File References** - Quick path lookup for all major files
6. **Environment Variables** - Integration-related env vars
7. **Testing Webhook Integration** - 3 test procedures
8. **Yacht Sales Specific** - Broker CRM, expiration, as-built examples
9. **Security Considerations** - 4 key points
10. **Performance Tips** - 3 optimization areas
---
## Key Findings At A Glance
### Architecture Status: PRODUCTION-READY
- Fully functional multi-tenancy
- Complete auth system with audit logging
- Database perfectly suited for boat documentation
- Security hardening implemented
### Database (13 Tables): EXCELLENT SCHEMA
- `entities`: Boats with full specs (HIN, vessel type, make, model, year)
- `components`: Engines, systems with serial numbers
- `documents`: Organized by type, linked to entities
- Metadata fields: JSON extensibility without schema changes
### API (40+ Endpoints): CORE FEATURES IMPLEMENTED
- Authentication ✅
- Multi-tenancy ✅
- Upload + OCR ✅
- Search ✅
- Permissions ✅
### Integrations: NOT IMPLEMENTED
- Home Assistant webhooks ❌
- MQTT publisher ❌
- Broker CRM sync ❌
- Cloud storage backends ❌
- But architecture supports all of these cleanly
### Gaps for Yacht Sales
| Gap | Impact | Priority |
|-----|--------|----------|
| No MLS/listing integration | Manual document organization | Critical |
| No sale workflow automation | No as-built package generation | Critical |
| No expiration tracking | Can't monitor surveys, certificates | Critical |
| Limited notifications | Missing key user alerts | High |
| No collaboration tools | No buyer sign-off, annotations | High |
| No video support | Document-only system | Medium |
| PWA partial implementation | Design done, code incomplete | Medium |
---
## How To Use These Documents
### Scenario 1: "I'm evaluating if this platform is suitable for yacht sales"
1. Read **ARCHITECTURE_ANALYSIS_SUMMARY.txt** (5 min)
2. Check "Gaps for Yacht Sales" section
3. Review "Recommended Next Steps"
4. Estimate effort needed to close gaps
### Scenario 2: "I need to implement Home Assistant integration"
1. Read **INTEGRATION_QUICK_REFERENCE.md** → "Webhook Receiver Pattern"
2. Check **ARCHITECTURE_INTEGRATION_ANALYSIS.md** → "Home Assistant Integration" section
3. Review database migration examples
4. Use code templates provided
### Scenario 3: "I'm reviewing the complete architecture"
1. Skim **ARCHITECTURE_ANALYSIS_SUMMARY.txt** for overview
2. Deep-dive into **ARCHITECTURE_INTEGRATION_ANALYSIS.md** sections in order
3. Use **INTEGRATION_QUICK_REFERENCE.md** for implementation details
### Scenario 4: "I'm implementing new features (notifications, webhooks)"
1. Reference **INTEGRATION_QUICK_REFERENCE.md** → "Service Layer Extension Points"
2. Check code patterns for your specific use case
3. Follow security and performance tips
4. Review file structure for where to place new code
---
## Key Files Referenced In Analysis
### Database
- `/home/setup/navidocs/server/db/schema.sql` - All 13 tables defined
### API Routes (12 files)
- `/home/setup/navidocs/server/routes/auth.routes.js` - Authentication
- `/home/setup/navidocs/server/routes/documents.js` - Document CRUD
- `/home/setup/navidocs/server/routes/upload.js` - File upload
- `/home/setup/navidocs/server/routes/search.js` - Meilisearch
- `/home/setup/navidocs/server/routes/organization.routes.js` - Multi-tenancy
- And 7 more...
### Services (11+ files)
- `/home/setup/navidocs/server/services/auth.service.js`
- `/home/setup/navidocs/server/services/queue.js`
- `/home/setup/navidocs/server/services/search.js`
- And 8 more...
### Workers (2 files)
- `/home/setup/navidocs/server/workers/ocr-worker.js`
- `/home/setup/navidocs/server/workers/image-extractor.js`
### Frontend
- `/home/setup/navidocs/client/src/views/` - 7 main pages
- `/home/setup/navidocs/client/src/components/` - 10+ reusable components
---
## Integration Roadmap Summary
### Phase 1: Foundation (1 week)
- Create integration framework
- Add webhook/event infrastructure
- Add yacht sales metadata templates
- Build notification system
### Phase 2: Core Integrations (2 weeks)
- Home Assistant webhook
- Broker CRM sync
- Cloud storage option
### Phase 3: Automation (2 weeks)
- As-built package generator
- Expiration tracking & alerts
- MQTT integration (optional)
**Total Timeline:** 4-6 weeks for MVP, 8-10 weeks for full feature set
---
## Architecture Strengths
1. **Clean Separation** - Routes, services, workers clearly separated
2. **Extensible** - JSON metadata, settings table, queue system ready for extensions
3. **Secure** - JWT, rate limiting, file validation, audit logging
4. **Multi-Tenant** - Organizations, user roles, entity hierarchies
5. **Search-First** - Meilisearch with tenant tokens, page-level indexing
---
## Next Steps After Reading
1. **Review the gaps** - Which integrations matter most for your use case?
2. **Estimate effort** - Use section 10 of main analysis for effort estimates
3. **Plan roadmap** - Decide which phase to start with
4. **Assign developer** - Use quick reference guide to onboard
5. **Start implementation** - Code templates provided, patterns documented
---
## Document Versions & Updates
All documents generated on: **2025-11-13**
If you need updates or additional analysis, regenerate from:
- Database schema: `/home/setup/navidocs/server/db/schema.sql`
- API routes: `/home/setup/navidocs/server/routes/`
- Services: `/home/setup/navidocs/server/services/`
- Workers: `/home/setup/navidocs/server/workers/`
---
## Questions This Analysis Answers
**"Is the database schema suitable for boats?"**
→ YES. Entities table has hull_id, vessel_type, make, model, year. Perfect fit.
**"Can we manage multiple boats per broker?"**
→ YES. Organizations → Entities hierarchy supports this.
**"What authentication features exist?"**
→ JWT, refresh tokens, password reset, email verification, audit logging.
**"Can documents expire/be monitored?"**
→ PARTIALLY. Schema supports it via metadata, need to implement notifications.
**"How do we integrate with Home Assistant?"**
→ Create /api/webhooks route, use event-bus service. 1-2 days work.
**"What's the timeline to add integrations?"**
→ 4-6 weeks for MVP with basic integrations, 8-10 weeks for full feature set.
**"Do we need to restructure the code?"**
→ NO. Architecture is designed for clean integration additions.
---
## Contact / Attribution
Analysis performed by: Claude Code (Haiku 4.5)
Analysis scope: Medium thoroughness
Methodology: Schema analysis, API endpoint mapping, service layer review, integration point identification
Generated for: NaviDocs Project
Date: 2025-11-13
---
**Start reading:** ARCHITECTURE_ANALYSIS_SUMMARY.txt (if new)
**Continue with:** ARCHITECTURE_INTEGRATION_ANALYSIS.md (if deep dive needed)
**Reference guide:** INTEGRATION_QUICK_REFERENCE.md (during implementation)