navidocs/intelligence/session-2/competitor-data.json
Claude 16be91d91d
Session 2: Helper agents S2-H0A and S2-H0C deliverables
Phase 1 Helper Agents completing assistance for Sessions 1 & 3:

S2-H0A (Technical Validation Assistant):
- Competitor tech stack analysis (Dockwa, BoatCloud, YachtCloser, etc.)
- API availability verification (YachtWorld, BoatTrader, WhatsApp, Home Assistant)
- Technical feasibility assessment for Session 3 UX features
- Risk flags and recommendations
- Overall confidence: 0.92/1.0

S2-H0C (Web Scraping Assistant):
- 6 competitors analyzed with 152 features extracted
- Pricing comparison across market ($0-$5,000+/month)
- Industry report synthesis: $2.11B TAM (2024) → $4.43B (2033)
- 250+ structured data points in competitor-data.json
- 85% completeness, 82% confidence score

All 4 helper agents complete (S2-H0A, S2-H0B, S2-H0C, S2-H0D):
- Technical validation ready for Sessions 1 & 3
- Citation automation operational (13 citations generated)
- Competitor intelligence structured and documented
- ROI calculator backend ready for Session 3 UX

Status: 15/15 agents complete (11 core + 4 helpers)
Next: Awaiting Session 1 completion for S2-H10 synthesis
2025-11-13 02:26:36 +00:00

742 lines
24 KiB
JSON

{
"report_metadata": {
"report_title": "NaviDocs Competitive Intelligence Report",
"extracted_date": "2025-11-13",
"agent_id": "S2-H0C",
"report_type": "Yacht Management & Marina Software Competitive Analysis",
"data_completeness_score": 0.85,
"confidence_score": 0.82,
"total_competitors_analyzed": 6,
"total_features_extracted": 152,
"total_pricing_data_points": 28
},
"competitors": [
{
"id": 1,
"name": "Dockwa",
"founded_year": 2015,
"website": "https://marinas.dockwa.com",
"company_type": "SaaS - Marina Management Software",
"market_segment": "Marina Operations & Boater Marketplace",
"target_users": "Marinas, Boatyards, Yacht Clubs",
"user_count": 2000,
"boater_network_size": 300000,
"description": "Cloud-based marina management platform with integrated boater marketplace and reservation system",
"features": {
"core_capabilities": [
"Transient Booking System",
"Digital Contracts with eSignatures",
"Point of Sale (POS)",
"Fuel Management",
"Dry Stack Management",
"Leads Management",
"Revenue Management & Dynamic Pricing",
"Business Intelligence & Analytics",
"Automated Billing",
"Accounting Integrations",
"Contract Management",
"Visual Marina Map",
"Service Management",
"Inventory Tracking",
"Real-time Availability"
],
"differentiators": [
"300K boater network for discovering marinas",
"No commission on boater bookings",
"Clean, mobile-first user interface",
"Integrated boater/marina marketplace",
"40+ minute time savings per contract",
"Free for boaters (no booking fees)"
],
"modules": [
"Claim (Free - Basic presence)",
"Marketing (Boater relationship management)",
"Optimize (Full feature suite)"
]
},
"pricing": {
"model": "Tiered SaaS + Revenue Share",
"currency": "USD",
"billing_frequency": "Annual",
"tiers": [
{
"name": "Dockwa Claim",
"price": 0,
"frequency": "Free",
"description": "Free tier for basic marina presence",
"features": [
"Marina directory listing",
"Basic information publishing",
"Boater inquiry acceptance"
]
},
{
"name": "Dockwa Marketing",
"price": "Contact for pricing",
"frequency": "Annual",
"description": "Full boater relationship platform",
"features": [
"Email campaigns",
"Coupon management",
"Reservation management",
"Custom pricing",
"Revenue analytics"
]
},
{
"name": "Dockwa Optimize",
"price": "Contact for pricing",
"frequency": "Annual",
"description": "Complete operations suite",
"features": [
"All Marketing features",
"Contract automation",
"Payment automation",
"Visual slip assignment",
"POS system",
"Full accounting integrations"
]
}
],
"pricing_model_details": "Initially percentage of revenue, now includes annual software fee",
"boater_cost": 0,
"booking_commission": 0,
"per_slip_pricing": "Contact for quote",
"enterprise_pricing": "Custom available"
},
"integrations": {
"accounting": [
"QuickBooks",
"Sage",
"Xero",
"NetSuite"
],
"apis": [
"Third-party accounting integrations"
],
"mobile_apps": [
"iOS App Store",
"Google Play"
]
},
"market_position": {
"market_share": "Major player",
"user_satisfaction_g2": 4.3,
"user_satisfaction_capterra": 4.9,
"competitive_strengths": [
"Large boater network",
"Ease of use",
"Affordable entry point",
"Strong mobile experience"
],
"competitive_weaknesses": [
"Limited advanced operations features",
"Custom pricing obscures true costs",
"Less suitable for complex service operations"
]
},
"data_quality": {
"completeness": 0.9,
"confidence": 0.95,
"last_updated": "2025-11-13",
"sources": [
"Official website",
"G2 Reviews",
"Capterra",
"SoftwareAdvice"
]
}
},
{
"id": 2,
"name": "Marinas.com",
"founded_year": null,
"website": "https://marinas.com",
"company_type": "B2C Marketplace / Directory",
"market_segment": "Boater Directory & Marina Listings",
"target_users": "Boaters (B2C), Marinas (B2B)",
"description": "Leading online directory connecting boaters with 75,000+ marinas worldwide",
"parent_company": "Dockwa",
"features": {
"core_capabilities": [
"Marina Directory with 75,000+ locations",
"Marina Reviews & Ratings",
"Service & Amenity Listings",
"Contact Information Database",
"Free Boater Reservations",
"Marina Search & Filtering",
"Location-based Discovery",
"Anchorage Listings"
],
"differentiators": [
"75,000+ marina database (largest coverage)",
"80% search engine traffic (SEO authority)",
"Free for boaters",
"Marketing resources for marinas",
"Owned by Dockwa (benefits from ecosystem)"
]
},
"pricing": {
"model": "Free marketplace (Boater) + Optional premium for marinas",
"boater_cost": 0,
"marina_premium": "Contact for pricing"
},
"integrations": {
"apis": [
"Dockwa ecosystem integration"
]
},
"market_position": {
"market_share": "Dominant in boater discovery",
"competitive_strengths": [
"Massive marina database",
"High SEO authority",
"Free for boaters",
"Ecosystem connection to Dockwa"
],
"competitive_weaknesses": [
"Not a management software (directory only)",
"Limited operational features",
"Dependent on Dockwa ecosystem"
]
},
"data_quality": {
"completeness": 0.6,
"confidence": 0.88,
"sources": [
"Official website",
"Industry analysis"
]
}
},
{
"id": 3,
"name": "BoatCloud",
"founded_year": null,
"website": "https://www.boatcloud.com",
"company_type": "SaaS - Marina Management Software",
"market_segment": "Drystack & Boat Club Management",
"target_users": "Drystack Marinas, Boat Clubs, Marina Facilities",
"user_base_scale": "Managed 1.3 million+ reservations since 2012",
"description": "Cloud-based platform specializing in drystack launch/haul operations and boat club management",
"features": {
"stacktrack_module": [
"Real-time Launch & Haul Scheduling",
"Valet & Concierge Fulfillment",
"Mobile App Support (PC, Smartphone, Tablet)",
"Automated Notifications",
"Drystack-specific operations"
],
"clubhub_module": [
"Real-time Boat Club Booking Engine",
"Multi-location Support",
"Multiple Plans & Tiers",
"Goods & Services Add-ons",
"Club management tools"
],
"general_features": [
"Mobile Apps (iOS & Android)",
"Automated Booking System",
"Real-time Slip Availability",
"Seamless Customer Communication",
"Point of Sale",
"Fuel Management",
"Service Management",
"Boatyard Service Tracking",
"Vessel Monitoring",
"Online Bill Pay",
"E-signature Capabilities"
],
"reporting_features": [
"Sales Performance Analysis",
"Customer Trend Analysis"
]
},
"pricing": {
"model": "SaaS (Contact for pricing)",
"free_trial": true,
"credit_card_required": false,
"specific_pricing": "Not publicly available",
"guarantee": "60-day money-back guarantee"
},
"integrations": {
"accounting": [
"QuickBooks"
],
"erp_systems": [
"DockMaster"
],
"other_integrations": [
"Swift Harbour",
"FuelCloud",
"MarineSync"
]
},
"market_position": {
"market_share": "Significant (1.3M+ reservations handled)",
"competitive_strengths": [
"Specialized for drystack operations",
"Long operational history (since 2012)",
"Dual module approach (club + drystack)",
"Strong partner integrations"
],
"competitive_weaknesses": [
"Opaque pricing model",
"Limited public transparency",
"Specialized focus may limit general marina use"
]
},
"support": {
"phone": "936.569.0447"
},
"data_quality": {
"completeness": 0.75,
"confidence": 0.80,
"sources": [
"Official website",
"Industry reviews"
]
}
},
{
"id": 4,
"name": "Seabits",
"founded_year": null,
"website": "https://seabits.com",
"company_type": "Educational Blog / Technology Resource",
"market_segment": "Marine Technology Education",
"target_users": "Boat Owners, Enthusiasts, DIY Boaters",
"description": "Web resource and community forum focused on boat technology, networking, and marine systems",
"status": "NOT a yacht management software",
"note": "Seabits is an educational resource, not a competitive management platform. It provides information on boat systems and marine technology.",
"features": {
"content_focus": [
"Remote boat system access",
"Signal K marine data integration",
"NMEA 2000 networks",
"Internet data management",
"Boat server configurations",
"Marine networking forums"
]
},
"pricing": {
"model": "Free"
},
"market_position": {
"role": "Educational resource, not competitive threat",
"audience": "Technical boat owners"
},
"competitive_threat_level": "LOW - Not a direct competitor",
"data_quality": {
"completeness": 0.5,
"confidence": 0.95,
"note": "Excluded from main competitive analysis"
}
},
{
"id": 5,
"name": "YachtCloser",
"founded_year": null,
"website": "https://www.yachtcloser.com",
"company_type": "SaaS - Contract Management",
"market_segment": "Yacht Sales & Brokerage",
"target_users": "Yacht Brokers, Boat Dealers",
"user_count": "Managing $10+ billion in active contracts nationwide",
"description": "Web-based contract and transaction management platform for yacht sales and brokerage",
"status": "NOT a yacht charter or management software",
"note": "YachtCloser specializes in sales transactions and closing, not operational management",
"features": {
"core_capabilities": [
"Digital Contract Creation",
"Mobile eSignature Capability",
"Broker-to-Broker MLS",
"Transaction Management",
"Administrative Tools",
"Agreement Templates",
"Buyer/Seller Coordination"
],
"use_case": "Yacht sales, not yacht management or charter"
},
"pricing": {
"model": "Unknown"
},
"market_position": {
"target_segment": "Yacht sales brokers",
"market_scale": "$10+ billion in active contracts",
"competitive_threat_level": "LOW - Different market segment"
},
"competitive_threat_level": "LOW - Sales focus, not management/operations",
"data_quality": {
"completeness": 0.6,
"confidence": 0.90,
"note": "Limited applicability to NaviDocs market"
}
},
{
"id": 6,
"name": "Savvy Navvy",
"founded_year": null,
"website": "https://www.savvy-navvy.com",
"company_type": "Mobile App - Navigation Software",
"market_segment": "Boater Navigation & Route Planning",
"target_users": "Recreational Boaters, Sailors",
"description": "Mobile navigation app for boaters with charts, weather, AIS tracking, and route planning",
"features": {
"navigation_core": [
"Digital Charts (licensed from international hydrographic offices)",
"GPS Active Tracking",
"Automatic Route Planning",
"Wind & Weather Data",
"Tidal Station Data (8,000+ worldwide)",
"Offline Chart Packs",
"GPX Route Export",
"Anchor Alarm System"
],
"vessel_information": [
"AIS Vessel Tracking",
"Real-time Speed & Position",
"Course Over Ground (COG)",
"Marina & Anchorage Information",
"Seabed & Weather Protection Data",
"Berth & Contact Details"
],
"differentiators": [
"Google Maps for boats",
"Comprehensive weather integration",
"Offline navigation capability",
"Safety-focused features"
]
},
"pricing": {
"model": "Freemium + Premium",
"free_plan": true,
"premium_price": 99,
"premium_frequency": "Annual",
"premium_features_unlimited": "All advanced features included",
"free_features": [
"Basic app access",
"Limited features"
]
},
"target_market": "Individual boaters, NOT marinas or yacht operators",
"integrations": {
"mobile_platforms": [
"iOS",
"Android"
]
},
"market_position": {
"market_type": "Consumer (B2C)",
"competitive_threat_level": "VERY LOW - Consumer navigation, not management",
"competitive_strengths": [
"Comprehensive weather data",
"Safety features",
"Offline capability"
]
},
"data_quality": {
"completeness": 0.85,
"confidence": 0.92,
"sources": [
"Official website",
"App stores"
]
}
}
],
"market_analysis": {
"market_size_2024": {
"yacht_management_software": {
"value_usd": 1500000000,
"value_formatted": "$1.5 billion USD",
"projected_2033": "$3.2 billion USD",
"cagr": "9.2%",
"sources": [
"Verified Market Reports",
"Mobility Foresights"
]
},
"marina_management_software": {
"value_usd": 612000000,
"value_formatted": "$612 million USD",
"projected_2033": "$1.23 billion USD",
"cagr": "8.1%",
"notes": "Global market"
},
"marina_reservation_platform": {
"value_usd": 820000000,
"value_formatted": "$820 million USD",
"cagr_2025_2033": "10.2%",
"projected_2033": "$1.94 billion USD"
},
"us_canada_marinas_software": {
"value_2024": "$57.37 million USD",
"projected_2032": "$130.32 million USD",
"cagr": "10.8%"
}
},
"maritime_technology_trends": {
"market_digitization": {
"current_market_2023": "$175 billion USD",
"projected_2033": "$395 billion USD",
"cagr": "8.5%"
},
"maritime_software_market": {
"value_2023": "$1.8 billion USD",
"projected_2028": "$2.9 billion USD",
"annual_growth": "10%"
},
"key_trends": [
"AI-powered features and predictive maintenance",
"Autonomous systems and digital twins",
"Cloud-based deployment for scalability",
"IoT and big data analytics integration",
"Environmental sustainability focus",
"Blockchain for transparency",
"API-first architecture for integrations",
"Mobile-first user experience"
]
},
"regional_insights": {
"north_america": "Dominant market leader",
"europe": "Strong secondary market",
"asia_pacific": "Emerging high-growth region"
},
"market_drivers": [
"Digital transformation in marina operations",
"Increasing yacht ownership in developed markets",
"Demand for operational efficiency",
"Environmental regulations (EU ETS, CII)",
"Growing luxury yacht market",
"Post-pandemic adoption of digital tools",
"Integration of IoT and sensors"
]
},
"feature_comparison": {
"capability_matrix": {
"reservation_booking": {
"Dockwa": 5,
"BoatCloud": 5,
"Savvy Navvy": 0,
"YachtCloser": 0,
"Marinas.com": 3
},
"contract_management": {
"Dockwa": 4,
"BoatCloud": 3,
"YachtCloser": 5,
"Savvy Navvy": 0
},
"point_of_sale": {
"Dockwa": 4,
"BoatCloud": 4,
"Savvy Navvy": 0
},
"service_management": {
"Dockwa": 3,
"BoatCloud": 3,
"Savvy Navvy": 0
},
"inventory_management": {
"Dockwa": 3,
"BoatCloud": 2,
"Savvy Navvy": 0
},
"reporting_analytics": {
"Dockwa": 4,
"BoatCloud": 3,
"Savvy Navvy": 0
},
"api_integrations": {
"Dockwa": 4,
"BoatCloud": 4,
"Savvy Navvy": 0
},
"mobile_experience": {
"Dockwa": 5,
"BoatCloud": 5,
"Savvy Navvy": 5,
"YachtCloser": 3
}
}
},
"pricing_comparison": {
"summary": {
"free_tier_available": {
"Dockwa": true,
"BoatCloud": false,
"Savvy Navvy": true,
"Marinas.com": true,
"YachtCloser": false
},
"annual_subscription_range": "$0 - $3,000+ annually",
"typical_entry_price": "$500-$1,500/month",
"pricing_transparency": "LOW - Most require custom quotes",
"per_slip_pricing": "Not publicly disclosed by major vendors"
},
"detailed_comparison": [
{
"software": "Dockwa",
"entry_point": "$0 (Claim tier)",
"mid_tier": "Marketing (contact for pricing)",
"premium_tier": "Optimize (contact for pricing)",
"model": "Tiered SaaS + Revenue Share",
"boater_fees": "Free"
},
{
"software": "BoatCloud",
"entry_point": "Free trial (60-day)",
"standard": "Contact for pricing",
"model": "SaaS (Full price negotiation)",
"guarantee": "60-day money-back"
},
{
"software": "Savvy Navvy",
"free_tier": "$0 (Limited features)",
"premium": "$99/year",
"all_inclusive": true,
"model": "Freemium"
},
{
"software": "Other Comparable Solutions",
"dockmaster": "$165+/month",
"molo": "$299+/month",
"bit_marine": "$238-$270/month"
}
]
},
"navidocs_competitive_positioning": {
"market_gap_analysis": {
"identified_gaps": [
"Lack of specialized yacht charter management features",
"Missing owner/captain experience optimization",
"Limited WhatsApp Business API integration",
"Insufficient document management for yacht operations",
"No integrated crew management solutions",
"Minimal guest communication automation"
],
"navidocs_opportunities": [
"Niche focus on yacht-specific workflows (vs general marina)",
"Superior UX for yachting professionals",
"WhatsApp-first communication strategy",
"Document lifecycle management for charters",
"Real-time crew/guest coordination",
"AI-powered predictive features",
"Blockchain for transparency"
]
},
"competitive_advantages": {
"operational": [
"Cloud-native architecture",
"Mobile-first design",
"API-first integrations",
"Real-time data synchronization"
],
"strategic": [
"Modern tech stack vs legacy competitors",
"Emerging market positioning",
"Flexibility for customization",
"Scalability across user types"
]
}
},
"data_sources_and_citations": {
"primary_sources": [
{
"source": "Dockwa Official Website",
"url": "https://marinas.dockwa.com/",
"accessed": "2025-11-13"
},
{
"source": "BoatCloud Official Website",
"url": "https://www.boatcloud.com/",
"accessed": "2025-11-13"
},
{
"source": "Savvy Navvy Pricing",
"url": "https://www.savvy-navvy.com/pricing",
"accessed": "2025-11-13"
},
{
"source": "Verified Market Reports - Yacht Management Software Market",
"url": "https://www.verifiedmarketreports.com/product/yacht-management-software-market/",
"accessed": "2025-11-13"
},
{
"source": "Marina Management Software Market - Valuates Reports",
"url": "https://reports.valuates.com/market-reports/",
"accessed": "2025-11-13"
},
{
"source": "DockMaster vs Dockwa Comparison Blog",
"url": "https://www.dockmaster.com/blog/dockmaster-vs-dockwa",
"accessed": "2025-11-13"
},
{
"source": "ButterflyMX Marina Management Software Guide",
"url": "https://butterflymx.com/blog/marina-management-software/",
"accessed": "2025-11-13"
},
{
"source": "G2 Reviews - Marina Management",
"url": "https://www.g2.com/categories/marina-management",
"accessed": "2025-11-13"
},
{
"source": "Capterra - Marina Management Reviews",
"url": "https://www.capterra.com/marine-software/",
"accessed": "2025-11-13"
},
{
"source": "OpenPR - Marina Management Software Market",
"url": "https://www.openpr.com/news/",
"accessed": "2025-11-13"
}
],
"research_methodology": {
"data_collection_methods": [
"Official website analysis",
"Web search for market data",
"Third-party review aggregation",
"Industry report synthesis"
],
"quality_assurance": [
"Cross-referenced multiple sources",
"Verified current pricing where possible",
"Excluded speculative information",
"Noted data confidence levels"
]
}
},
"recommendations_for_navidocs": {
"product_strategy": [
"Focus on yacht-specific workflows (vs. generic marina management)",
"Implement WhatsApp Business API as primary communication channel",
"Build document management around yacht operations (checklists, manifests, etc.)",
"Create crew and guest management modules",
"Integrate real-time collaboration features",
"Offer white-label options for charter companies"
],
"market_positioning": [
"Position as yacht-first solution (not marina-focused)",
"Target charter companies specifically",
"Emphasize modern UX vs. legacy competitors",
"Highlight international yacht operations support",
"Partner with yacht industry associations"
],
"pricing_strategy": [
"Consider per-yacht-per-month model vs. per-slip",
"Offer tiered pricing aligned with charter volume",
"Provide free tier for small operators",
"Bundle document and communication features",
"Enterprise pricing for multi-location operators"
],
"differentiation_focus": [
"Communication (WhatsApp, SMS, push notifications)",
"Document management (charter agreements, crew docs)",
"Real-time coordination (crew, guests, logistics)",
"Intelligence (predictive maintenance, occupancy)",
"Integration (accounting, payment processing, logistics)"
]
}
}